Comments on: Weather-ology: Winter Spirit

By: Kate

Kate — Tue, 23 Apr 2013 20:12:19 +0000

My Dad always told me that the thunder was the old chuck wagon rolling across the clouds and the lightening was the old cook cracking his whip above the horses heads
to keep them moving on.
In the days when you had lots of programs on the radio stations to listen too you aquired a pretty good imagination and I could see the whole thing in my minds eye as he was telling it to me.
There may be some Indian in our blood line after all.

By: RW Steinberg

RW Steinberg — Sun, 02 Dec 2012 16:34:56 +0000

Here’s something to consider. The history of Native Americans on this continent and South America goes back about 10,000 years give or take so give them credit for being able to live off of the land. Case, in point. The Pacific Northwest Indians. There is or was a fabulous diorama exhibit at the Harvard Museum of Natural History. Next time you’re in Boston, go check it out. We should also remember that unlike the “Europeans”, NAtive American Tribes were a peaceful people. No doubt crossing over on the then existing land bridge to get away from the warring “Europeans”. Just a thought. “HOW”

By: Jaime McLeod

Jaime McLeod — Fri, 30 Nov 2012 15:12:44 +0000

On Wm Meyer’s joke – My editor has posted that same joke. I don’t think the point is to place European knowledge above traditional, native knowledge. I’d say it’s just the opposite (that meteorology is no less “magic” than weather lore). I think it’s a subtle poke at the assumptions we all make about other cultures. Most Native Americans today probably do get their weather information from the local news, yet white people mythologize them into something exotic. That’s the joke, in addition to the cyclical nature of the feedback loop that the tribe and the weather station got into.

By: Jaime McLeod

Jaime McLeod — Fri, 30 Nov 2012 15:07:41 +0000

Ellery, I’m glad you liked the story. I have no native blood, though my spouse is part Abenaki (maternal grandmother). We can all learn something from every culture.

By: Ellery

Ellery — Wed, 28 Nov 2012 18:21:48 +0000

After submitting my comments, I see another “joke” that subtly places the European on a higher plane than the “Indian”. I wish for “that someday, we will be beyond making fun of other’s cultures” but obviously not in my time.

By: Ellery

Ellery — Wed, 28 Nov 2012 18:13:42 +0000

Very good!! I sincerely believe we should be more attuned to the anishinabeg folklore of the Americas… at least as much as the Greek mythological tales, which are more suited to Europeans.
I see the author’s name is McLeod. In the area that I grew up, there are a few Métis
families with that name. If she is a Métis person, she should be very proud of her heritage as the Métis have a strong and powerful history that dates back to when the first Europeans landed on our shores. A couple of centuries later in the Canadian prairies , the French took to describing the resulting off springs as “half caste” and the name was used in a derogatory manner as the original term meant a “cur” or “mutt”, something that might be produced by wild dogs of two different breeds. Pretty scathing for a culture that cleared the way to better understanding and respect for both the interlopers and the indigenous peoples… that is what one would have liked to happen. We all know where that has gone.
But all in all, it’s good to finally see some indigenous mythology as I think it is more relevant to this continent.

By: Wm Meyer

Wm Meyer — Wed, 28 Nov 2012 17:47:07 +0000

Weather-ology story Old Indian Chief died early one fall young son took over as chief braves came one day ask new chief how much wood to cut for winter (old chief would tell them) young chief said possibly mild winter but cut plenty wood one day as young chief walked to town he say a building that said Weather Station so he called the station and they said think mild to cold winter young chief went to tribe and said better cut more wood possoble colder winter than normal few weeks chief called weather station ask about weather we believe much colder than normal young chief said to tribe heavy winter colder than normal better cut more wood few days later chief called weather station ask about future weather we believe going to be really cold winter chief said by the way how do you gather information to predict weather they said we have been watching the indians and they have been choping more wood than normal so we predict very cold winter