Why Do We Break a Wishbone for Good Luck?
Long before Thanksgiving became an American holiday, people were pulling apart the forked bones of birds and hoping for good fortune. The custom is centuries old, and the winner wasn’t always wishing for something. In some versions, the prize was a prediction about who would marry first.
Today, breaking the turkey’s wishbone is a familiar Thanksgiving tradition. Two people each take one end, make a wish, and pull. Whoever ends up with the larger piece is supposed to have their wish granted.
But how did a little bone become a symbol of good luck?
Quick Reference: The Thanksgiving Wishbone Tradition
- The tradition: Two people pull apart a dried turkey wishbone. Whoever gets the larger piece is said to receive good luck or a granted wish.
- Its origins: Often linked to ancient Etruscan and Roman divination, although the precise historical connection is uncertain.
- Its old name: In England, the bone was called a “merrythought.” The custom was known by the early 1600s.
- Why it’s called a wishbone: The American English name appeared in the 19th century.
- What it actually is: The furcula, a pair of fused collarbones found in birds and some dinosaurs.
The Ancient Origins of the Wishbone Tradition
The most popular explanation begins with the Etruscans, who lived in ancient Italy before the rise of Rome.
According to a widely repeated account, the Etruscans believed chickens could reveal the future. They supposedly saved the birds’ forked bones and touched them while making wishes.
The Romans are said to have adopted the practice, eventually breaking the bones apart rather than simply touching them.
It’s a colorful origin story, but the details are difficult to verify. Bird divination was practiced in the ancient Mediterranean world, although a direct connection between those rituals and the modern wishbone game hasn’t been firmly established.
The history becomes clearer in England, where breaking the bone was already a familiar pastime by the 1600s.
Before It Was a Wishbone, It Was a “Merrythought”
For centuries, English speakers called the bone a merrythought.
The game was much like the one played today, although the person holding the longer piece might supposedly be the first to marry rather than the recipient of a granted wish.
The word wishbone appeared much later, in 19th-century American English. According to the Online Etymology Dictionary, it dates to around 1860.
The name stuck, and the wishbone became particularly associated with Thanksgiving, when a turkey provided a convenient opportunity for the family ritual.
It also joined a long collection of household superstitions involving food. Farmers’ Almanac explores several others in Food Superstitions: Knock on Wood, Spill the Salt, and 10 More Kitchen Traditions.
What Exactly Is a Wishbone?
The wishbone is actually a pair of fused collarbones, called the furcula. It sits near the front of a bird’s chest and helps support its shoulders during movement.
And turkeys aren’t the only animals with one.
Scientists have found wishbones in fossils of meat-eating dinosaurs, including Tyrannosaurus rex. The Smithsonian explains that this distinctive bone is part of the evolutionary connection between modern birds and their dinosaur ancestors.
That’s quite a history for something you might find on your Thanksgiving plate.
How to Break a Wishbone
The traditional game is simple:
- Remove the wishbone from the cooked turkey and carefully clean off any remaining meat.
- Allow it to dry thoroughly. A dry wishbone generally snaps more easily than a fresh one.
- Have two people hold opposite ends of the bone, each making a silent wish.
- Pull until it breaks.
According to the familiar superstition, whoever holds the larger piece gets the wish.
Of course, there’s no evidence that a broken turkey bone can change anyone’s luck. But after centuries of wishing, pulling, and comparing pieces, it’s easy to see why the tradition has survived.




